Yesterday I was talking to an acquaintance about books and book writing,
She asked me about writing and about reviewing,
First she wanted to know how could I review a book, particularly one that I didn't like,
I told her to define like,
She said, 'Not your cup of tea,'
I laughed because I love all kinds of tea,
Which is mostly determined by my mood,
Well-written contemporary, women's fiction is my favorite tea,
Closely followed by literary fiction tea and timely non-fiction tea,
However, on any given day, I will change tea and tea time,
So, when doing a review, I have to take "Me" out of it and read the book from the,
Perspective of how well it was written, did it make any sense, engage me, enlighten me or entertain me...
Given that criteria, I feel I can write a fair review,
For me most books have fallen into the 4 range, average to above average,
I have encountered few true 5s,
And very few below 3s,
But that is all opionion I grant you,
If I truly can't fairly review a book, I pass it on,
She then asked me how I deal with reviews,
I told her with a grain of salt,
As with anyone, I love favorable reviews,
And no one has ever bashed my books,
At least not within my hearing range or so that I could see it in print,
But I have been told that most of that kind of thing is usually undercover or the infamous off-loop...I try to avoid all of that,
With my first book, many reviewed it on the storyline,
Those were good reviews,
Others reviewed it on the style and editing and those were average reviews,
I found them all to be fair,
The best reviews I have received of course are from those readers who tell me how they felt or how my work impacted them or even what they didn't like,
Those are the ones I learn the most from and the ones I remember when writing the next book,
I also tell writers who are not feeling how I have reviewed them,
'When you place your work in the hands of a reviewer, going in understanding that the reviewer can only review from his or her perspective, and that in most cases it is business and not personal. Always adding my true belief that everything is not for everybody, and as writers we have to constantly remind ourselves of this. Tea is a preferred taste in it's variations.'
Love and Blessings,
angelia
Writer, Reader, Reviewer
WRITE OR DIE WOMAN, BRINGING THE FICITIONALIZED TRUTH IN BOOK,EBOOK AND BLOG FORM...
Angelia Vernon Menchan
Angelia Vernon Menchan is an author, publisher and public speaker who owns two publishing companies, MAMM Productions and Honorable Menchan Media. Mrs. Menchan is also a Budget Officer and former Job Corps Counselor. To date she has published twenty-three books of her own work, both fiction and non-fiction and more than eighty ebook novellas on amazon.com. You can access her bibliography on www.amazon.com search words: Angelia Vernon Menchan
Contact information:
Website: http://acvermen.blogspot.com
Email: acvermen@yahoo.com
Phone numbers: 904 714 2272 904 303 2679
Contact information:
Website: http://acvermen.blogspot.com
Email: acvermen@yahoo.com
Phone numbers: 904 714 2272 904 303 2679
8 comments:
I love the tea analogy because I love me some tea and I love me some books. And I love to sample and dabble in both. ;-)
At the end of the day it really is subjective. And we would be wise to take any review, even high praise with a grain of salt...
Great post, sis.
Gwyneth
That is exactly it Lady Gwyneth, we take ourselves way too seriously sometimes, and a great way to get past all that is with a good book and nice tea!
Happy Sipping and Reading!
angelia
I agree with Gwyneth on this.
A review is the opinion of the reviewer. It is not our job to critique the work or the writer. We are to give an overview to the perspective buyer and allow them to make a choice.
Linda!
So, when doing a review, I have to take "Me" out of it and read the book from the,
Perspective of how well it was written, did it make any sense, engage me, enlighten me or entertain me...
Given that criteria, I feel I can write a fair review,
And that's what makes you such a good and objective (rather than subjective reviewer). Glad to have you on the AET!
xoxo
Thanks Linda,
Thanks Yas,
I love AET...
smooches,
angelia
I don't think I've ever laughed some much when reading one of your blogs. I love tea my self and the analogy as well.
I don't think I could've explained it any better.
Jen,
tea anyone!
smooches,
angelia
Yup...just like that.
Love it and it goes to show you can write a review for an author and reader...that's what I love about reviewing.
Great post!
I'm feeling some mint tea tonight...lol
Hugs and smiles
G-Nice
Post a Comment